Published: March 2023
This book provides a comprehensive introduction to international trade and cargo insurance, before outlining the various requirements for insurable interests reflecting the fundamental indemnity principle of marine insurance and the legal prohibition against gaming and wagering. It also explains marine open cover and details insuring clauses alongside the inherent vice and delay exclusions from specific clauses. To give the reader an understanding of insurance contracts, contract certainty in policies is explained before discussing the cargo claims and the cargo recovery process.
The second edition has been expanded to address the many changes in marine insurance law since the release of the first edition. These developments include the ‘Cendor MOPU’, newer editions of Institute Cargo and Trade Clauses, developing case laws, the Insurance Act 2015 and Incoterms 2020, to mention a few. New chapters in the book also include delay and inherent vice exclusions, war and strikes, rejection risks, contract certainty in policies, non-Institute Clauses and recoveries. The insurable interest and contingency chapters have also been revised as the expected reforms in this regard have not been undertaken.
This book will be of great use to practitioners as a complement to more academic texts. It is commended to any reader interested in marine cargo insurance and is a useful tool for law firms, underwriters, adjusters and surveyors.
Table of Contents
About the Author | 7.6 Insuring Inherent Vice |
Foreword to the 1st Edition | 7.7 Summary |
Foreword to the 2nd Edition | 7.8 Delay |
Preface to the 2nd Edition | 7.9 Pre-MIA 1906 Cases |
Abbreviations | 7.9.1 Taylor v Dunbar (1869) |
Case Law List | 7.9.2 Pink and Others v Fleming (1890) |
1. Introduction to International Trade and Cargo Insurance | 7.10 Post-1906 Cases |
1.1 Cargo Families | 7.10.1 Becker Gray & Co v London Assurance Corporation (the ‘Kattenturm’) (1918) |
1.2 Dangerous Goods | 7.10.2 Leyland Shipping Co Ltd v Norwich Union Fire Insurance Society Ltd (1918) |
1.3 Ships and their Classification | 7.10.3 Yorkshire Dale Steamship Co Ltd v Minister of War Transport (the ‘Coxwold’) (1942) |
1.4 Flag of Convenience (FOC) | 7.11 The Delay Exclusion in ICC 1982/2009 |
1.5 Classification | 7.12 Scenarios |
1.6 Chartered Ships | 7.13 FCA Test Case |
1.7 Protection and Indemnity Clubs | 8. Insuring Terms 3 – Named Perils |
1.8 The ISM Code | 8.1 Institute Cargo Clauses (B) and (C) |
1.9 The ISPS Code | 8.2 (B) and (C) Causation Rules |
1.10 Ship Selection | 8.3 (B) and (C) Perils: Subject to Reasonably Attributable to |
1.11 The Container Revolution | 8.3.1 Fire or Explosion |
1.12 Mechanism of Containerisation | 8.3.2 Stranded, Grounded, Sunk or Capsized |
1.13 Verified Gross Mass (VGM) | 8.3.3 Overturning and Derailment of Land Conveyance |
1.14 Impact on Marine Insurance | 8.3.4 Collision or Contact |
1.15 Financing of International Trade | 8.3.5 Discharge of Cargo at a Port of Distress |
1.16 Cargo Insurance and International Trade | 8.3.6 Earthquake, Volcanic Eruption or Lightning |
1.17 Responsibility to Arrange Cargo Insurance | 8.4 (B) and (C) Perils: Subject to Caused by |
1.18 Insurance | 8.4.1 General Average Sacrifice |
1.19 Impediments to Trade | 8.4.2 Jettison or Washing Overboard |
1.20 What is Marine Cargo Insurance? | 8.4.3 Entry of Water |
1.21 Marine Cargo Insurance Contract | 8.4.4 Total Loss of Package |
1.22 The Marine Cargo Policy | 8.5 General Average |
1.23 Principles Governing Marine Cargo Insurance | 8.6 Exclusions |
1.24 Utmost Good Faith | 8.7 Institute Theft, Pilferage and/or Non-Delivery CL.272, 01.12.82 |
1.25 Duty of Disclosure, S.18 | 8.8 Theft, Pilferage and/or Non-delivery (TPND) and Piracy |
1.26 Voidable Nature of Contract, S.18(1) | 9. Insuring Terms 4 – Trade Clauses |
1.27 Pre-Contractual Duty, S.18(1) | 9.1 Institute Clauses for Bulk Oils – Part 1 |
1.28 Continuing Duty (Post Contractual) | 9.2 Perils |
1.29 Materiality and Inducement, S.18(2) | 9.3 Leakage from Connecting Pipelines |
1.30 Exceptions to the Duty of Disclosure, S.18(3) | 9.4 Underground Pipelines |
1.31 Disclosure by Agent Effecting Insurance, S.19 | 9.5 Negligence during Pumping |
1.32 Representations Pending Negotiation of Contract | 9.6 Contamination from Stress of Weather |
1.33 Criticisms of the Law of Good Faith | 9.7 Exclusions |
1.34 The Insurance Act 2015 | 9.8 Duration |
1.35 Duty of Fair Representation | 9.9 Movements by Craft and Barge Tankers |
1.36 Impact of the Insurance Act 2015 | 9.10 Delivery of Whole Consignment or Each Portion Thereof? |
1.37 Proportional Remedies | 9.11 Adjustment Clause |
1.38 Preparation Needed Under the IA 2015 Regime | 9.11.1 Explanation |
1.39 Fraud and the Duty of Good Faith | 9.12 Readjustment of Claim |
1.40 Indemnity | 9.13 Contamination Claims – Need for All Risks Cover |
1.41 Agreed Value – A Detailed Discussion | 9.14 Institute Clauses for Bulk Oils – Part 2 |
1.42 Insurable Interest | 9.15 Institute Clauses for Bulk Oils – Part 3 |
1.43 Subrogation | 9.16 Exclusions |
1.44 Contribution | 9.17 JCC Storage Extension Clauses for Bulk Oils |
1.45 Common Liability Method | 9.18 Institute Coal Clauses: Clause No 393, 01.05.16 |
1.46 Independent Liability Method | 9.19 Heating and Spontaneous Combustion |
1.47 Maximum Liability Method | 9.20 Duration |
1.48 Warranties | 9.21 Craft Risks |
1.49 Types of Warranties | 9.22 Barging Risks |
1.50 Examples of Express Warranties in Cargo Insurance | 9.23 Institute Timber Trade Clause No 405, 01.05.16 |
1.51 The Literal Performance/Strict Compliance Rule under the MIA 1906 | 9.24 Piracy |
1.52 The Position under the Insurance Act 2015 | 9.25 Exclusions |
1.53 Burden of Proof | 9.26 Duration |
1.54 Contracting Out | 10. Insuring Terms 5 – Cargoes Requiring a Controlled Environment |
2. Insurable Interest 1 | 10.1 Types of Controlled Environment |
2.1 Introduction | 10.2 Underwriting Considerations |
2.2 Insurable Interest Defined | 10.3 Slow Steaming |
2.3 Legal or Equitable Relationship | 10.4 Temperature Recording Devices |
2.4 Prejudiced by Loss … Benefit by Safety | 10.4.1 Ryan Recorder (Analogue Temperature Recorder) |
2.5 Supreme Court of Canada’s View on Macaura | 10.4.2 Data Loggers |
2.6 Supreme Court of Canada’s View on Broadgrain Commodities | 10.4.3 TempTale® (and Other Digital Temperature Recorders) |
2.7 Insurable Interests in Cargo | 10.4.4 Sensors/Probes |
2.8 International Trade under Contracts of Sale | 10.4.5 Remote Sensing Systems |
2.9 Risk v Title Dichotomy | 10.5 Institute/JCC Clauses for Frozen/Chilled Foods and Meat |
2.10 Timing of Insurable Interest | 10.6 Changes in 2017 Edition |
2.11 Lost or Not Lost | 10.7 Institute Clauses for Frozen Foods |
2.12 Assignment of Policy and Interest | 10.8 Peril Clauses |
2.13 Interplay of Various Sections of the MIA 1906 | 10.8.1 Institute Frozen/Chilled Food Clauses (C), Clause No 431 |
2.14 Insurable Interest of a Buyer | 10.8.2 Institute Frozen/Chilled Food Clauses (A), 24 Hours Breakdown, Clause No 423 |
2.15 Insurable Interest of the CIF Seller | 10.8.3 Institute Frozen/Chilled Food Clauses (A), Clause No 430 |
2.16 Concluding Remarks | 10.9 Exclusions |
3. Insurable Interest 2 – Contingency Covers | 10.9.1 Inherent Vice |
3.1 Seller’s Interest | 10.9.2 Loss of Market |
3.2 Reasons for Rejection of Documents/Goods | 10.9.3 Refrigerated, Insulated and Cooled |
3.3 Key Features of Seller’s Interest Cover | 10.9.4 Embargo, Rejection, etc |
3.4 Additional Clauses in Seller’s Interest | 10.10 Duration Clause |
3.5 Contingency Cover for CIF/CIP Seller | 10.11 Frozen Food Extension Clause, No 422 |
3.6 Buyer’s Interest | 10.12 Frozen/Chilled Meat Extension Clauses, No 429 |
3.6.1 Stage of Transit | 10.13 War and Strikes – Institute Strikes Clauses (Frozen/Chilled Food), No 424 |
3.6.2 CIF Purchases | 10.14 Frozen/Chilled Meat |
3.6.3 Tail-end Risks | 10.15 Perils |
3.6.4 Difference in Conditions (DIC)/Difference in Limits (DIL) Extensions | 10.16 Exclusions |
3.7 Achieving Seamless Covers Irrespective of Terms of Sale | 10.17 Duration |
3.8 Guarantee of Collectability | 10.18 The Adjustment Clause |
4. Marine Open Cover | 10.19 War and Strikes – Institute Strikes Clauses (Frozen/Chilled Meat), No 428 |
4.1 What is an Open Cover? | 11. Insuring Terms 6 – Non-Institute Clauses |
4.2 Advantages | 11.1 Introduction |
4.3 Assured | 11.2 Accumulation |
4.4 Period | 11.3 Airfreight Replacement (Expediting Expenses) |
4.5 Cancellation Clause | 11.4 Apportionment of Recoveries |
4.6 Interest Insured | 11.5 Arrest |
4.7 Treatment of Packing Materials | 11.6 Art and Antiques (Depreciation) |
4.8 Conveyances | 11.7 Assured |
4.9 Use of Own Vehicles | 11.8 Bagged Cargo Clause |
4.10 Voyage/Geographical Limits | 11.9 Brand, Label and Trademark Protection |
4.11 Basis of Valuation | 11.9.1 Labels Clause |
4.12 Limits of Liability | 11.9.2 Brands and Trademark Clause |
4.13 Per Bottom Limit | 11.10 Control of Damaged Goods |
4.14 Location Limit | 11.11 Claused Bill of Lading |
4.15 Meaning of Location | 11.12 Commingling |
4.16 Accumulation at Ports of Loading and Discharge | 11.13 Concealed Damage (Delayed Discovery of Loss) |
4.17 Location Limit and Overseas Buyers | 11.14 Containers |
4.18 Limits and Co-Assureds | 11.14.1 Container Fitness |
4.19 Limits of Liability and Condition of Average | 11.14.2 Container Demurrage |
4.20 Limit Per Location and Freight Forwarders | 11.14.3 Container Handover |
4.21 Accumulation Clause | 11.14.4 Container Seals |
4.22 Terms of Cover | 11.15 Contingency |
4.23 Declaration (Bordereau) | 11.15.1 Incoterms® Rules Override Clause |
4.24 Late Declaration or Omission to Declare | 11.15.2 Cover for Fob (or Similar Purchases) |
4.25 Certificate of Insurance | 11.15.3 Seller’s Interest Cover |
4.26 Hold Harmless Clause | 11.15.4 Buyer’s Interest Cover |
4.27 Web-based Certificate Generation (E-Marine) | 11.16 Continuation Clause |
4.28 Certificate Versus Open Cover Terms | 11.17 Country Damage |
4.29 Nature of Open Cover Contract ‘for’ or Contract ‘of ’ Insurance | 11.18 Cutting Clause |
4.30 Certificate Issued for Individual Export Voyage | 11.19 Debris Removal |
4.31 Words of Incorporation in the Certificate | 11.20 Deck Cargo |
4.32 Certificate Mentioning the Open Cover Number | 11.21 Deductible Clause |
4.33 Certificate Mentioning ‘All Other Terms as Per Open Cover’ | 11.22 Duty/Customs Duty and Taxes |
4.34 Certificate Mentioning Entities ‘for Whom the Assured has Instruction to Insure’ | 11.23 Exchange Rate (Currency Conversion) |
4.35 Rights of an Unpaid Seller | 11.24 Export Subsidies and Similar |
4.36 Conclusion | 11.25 Fraudulent Bill of Lading |
4.37 Annual Sales Turnover Policies | 11.26 Full General Average |
4.38 Annual Sales Turnover Policies – A Critique | 11.27 Fumigation |
4.39 Cargo (Stock) Throughput Policies | 11.28 Governmental Damage |
4.40 Advantages of Stock Throughput Policies | 11.28.1 Customs Clause |
4.41 Illustrations of a Stock Throughput Policy | 11.28.2 Deliberate Damage – Pollution Hazard |
4.42 Challenges in Administering Stock Throughput Covers | 11.29 Jurisdiction |
4.43 Process Clause in Stock Throughput Covers | 11.30 Letter of Credit |
4.44 Standard Exclusions in a Stock Throughput Policy | 11.31 Loading and Unloading |
5. Insuring Terms 1 – Institute Classification Clause | 11.32 Location |
5.1 Main Provisions | 11.33 Mechanical and Electrical Derangement (MEED) |
5.2 Age Limitation | 11.33.1 Usage |
5.3 Non-qualifying Vessels | 11.33.2 Meaning |
5.4 Summary | 11.33.3 Damage Detection Devices – Shock and Tilt Monitors |
5.5 Transhipping Vessels | 11.34 Packing |
5.6 Craft | 11.35 Pair and Set |
5.7 Classification Clause | 11.36 Pipeline Clause |
5.8 SOLAS 1974 | 11.37 Peak Value/Automatic Increased Value |
5.9 The International Safety Management (ISM) Code | 11.38 Process |
5.9.1 ISM Code and Marine Insurance | 11.39 Reissue |
5.10 ISM Forwarding Charges | 11.40 Returned Goods |
5.10.1 Compliance with the ISM Code | 11.41 Salvage Loss |
5.11 Summary and Concluding Remarks | 11.42 Shut-out Shipment |
5.12 ISM and Classification | 11.43 Sight Draft Extension |
5.13 The International Ship and Port Facility Security (ISPS) Code | 11.44 Sorting/Segregation |
5.13.1 ISPS Endorsements | 11.45 Trade Loss |
5.13.2 ISPS – Implications for Cargo Assureds | 11.46 Travel and Accommodation |
6. Insuring Terms 2 – Institute Cargo Clauses (A), CL.382, 01.01.09 | 11.47 Waiver of Subrogation |
6.1 Background to Changes | 12. Insuring Terms 7 – War and Related Perils |
6.2 General Changes | 12.1 Institute War Clauses (Cargo) CL.385, 01.01.09 |
6.3 Major Changes | 12.2 Perils |
6.4 Perils Clause | 12.2.1 War |
6.4.1 All Risks | 12.2.2 Civil War |
6.4.2 General Average | 12.2.3 Revolution, Rebellion and Insurrection |
6.4.3 Both to Blame Collision Claus | 12.2.4 Civil Strife |
6.5 Exclusions | 12.2.5 Hostile Act by or against a Belligerent Power |
6.5.1 Wilful Misconduct | 12.2.6 Capture |
6.5.2 Ordinary Losses | 12.2.7 Seizure |
6.5.3 Poor Packaging | 12.2.8 Arrest |
6.5.4 Inherent Vice | 12.2.9 Restraint |
6.5.5 Delay | 12.2.10 Detainment |
6.5.6 Insolvency | 12.2.11 “… and the consequences thereof or any attempt thereat” |
6.5.7 Nuclear or Radioactive Devices | 12.2.12 Derelict Mines etc |
6.5.8 Unseaworthiness | 12.3 Exclusions |
6.5.9 Hostile Acts | 12.3.1 The Frustration Clause |
6.5.10 Strikes | 12.3.2 Hostile Use of Weapons or Devices |
6.6 Duration of Cover – 1 | 12.4 Waterborne Agreement |
6.6.1 Background to Duration Clause, 2009 Edition | 12.4.1 Duration |
6.7 The Duration Clause in ICC 2009 | 12.4.2 Reattachment Provision (‘Held Covered’) |
6.7.1 Attachment | 12.4.3 Craft |
6.7.2 Ordinary Course of Transit | 12.5 Institute Strike, Riot, Civil Commotion (SRCC) CL 386, 01.01.09 |
6.7.3 Termination | 12.5.1 Strike |
6.8 Duration Clause Scenarios | 12.5.2 Locked-out Workmen |
6.8.1 Attachment of Cover Scenarios | 12.5.3 Labour Disturbances |
6.8.2 Continuation Scenario | 12.5.4 Riot |
6.8.3 Termination Scenarios | 12.5.5 Civil Commotion |
6.9 Other Markets | 12.6 Terrorism |
6.10 Duration of Cover – 2 | 12.7 General Average (GA) |
6.10.1 Additional Premium under Clause 9 | 12.8 Exclusions |
6.10.2 Can the Insurer Deny Extension of Cover Upon Receiving Notice under Clause 9? | 12.8.1 Exclusion 3.7 |
6.11 Change of Voyage | 12.8.2 Exclusion 3.8 |
6.11.1 Clause 10.2 – the Phantom Ship | 12.8.3 Exclusion 3.10 |
6.12 Claims | 12.9 Cancellation Clause in Open Covers |
6.13 Forwarding Charges | 12.10 Institute Malicious Damage Clause, CL.266, 01.08.82 |
6.13.1 Clause 12 – a ‘Supplementary Contract’? | 12.11 Institute Radioactive Contamination (RACE) Clause |
6.14 Constructive Total Loss | 12.11.1 Extended Race Clause, No 356A/01.11.02 |
6.15 Increased Value | 12.11.2 Dirty Bombs |
6.16 Benefit of Insurance | 12.11.3 Further Amendment Clause, No 370/10.11.03 |
6.17 Minimising Losses | 12.11.4 Termination of Transit Clause (Terrorism) 2009, JC2009/056, 01.01.09 |
6.18 Waiver | 12.12 Cyber Attack |
6.19 Avoidance of Delay | 13. Rejection Risks |
6.20 Law and Practice | 13.1 Origin of Rejection Risks Covers |
6.21 Note | 13.2 Concurrent Causation – Applicability to Exclusion 6.2/6.4 |
6.22 Premium to be Arranged – is there an Upper Limit? | 13.3 Need for Rejection Risks |
7. Inherent Vice and Delay Exclusions | 13.4 Rejection Risks Insurance |
7.1 Inherent Vice | 13.5 Analysis of London May 1975 Rejection Clause |
7.2 Meaning of Inherent Vice | 13.6 Duration |
7.3 Examples of Inherent Vice | 13.6.1 Attachment |
7.4 Mechanism of Condensation | 13.6.2 Termination |
7.5 Leading Case Law on Inherent Vice | 13.7 Rejection Covers in other Major Markets |
7.5.1 E D Sassoon & Co Ltd v Yorkshire Insurance Co (1923) | 13.8 Underwriting Factors |
7.5.2 C T Bowring & Co Ltd v Amsterdam London Insurance Co Ltd (1930) | 13.9 Warranties |
7.5.3 Soya GmbH Mainz Kommanditgesellschaft v White (1983) | 14. Contract Certainty in Policies |
7.5.4 Noten BV v Harding (1990) | 14.1 Introduction |
7.5.5 Mayban General Insurance BHD v Alstom Power Plants Ltd (2004) | 14.2 Ambiguities |
7.5.6 Nelson Marketing International Inc v Royal and Sun Alliance Insurance Co of | 14.3 Contra Proferentem Rule |
Canada (2005) | 14.4 Ambiguities and Gaps in Coverage – Why they Arise |
7.5.7 Feuiltault Solution Systems Inc v Zurich Canada (2021) | 14.4.1 The Mining Industry |
7.5.8 Global PROCESS Systems Inc and Another v Syarikat Takaful Malaysia Berhad | 14.4.2 The Pharmaceutical Industry |
(the ‘Cendor MOPU’) (2011) | 14.5 Limitation to Contra Rule |
7.5.9 ACE European Group Ltd and Others v Chartis Insurance UK Ltd (2012) | 14.6 Interpreting Policy Terms – The Rise of Factual Matrix/Commercial Common Sense |